Bagelsmith - Bedford Ave.

Located on the vibrant stretch of Bedford Avenue in Brooklyn, Bagelsmith is a beloved gem for bagel lovers and breakfast aficionados alike. This cozy bagel shop and breakfast restaurant skillfully blends classic New York bagel traditions with contemporary, health-conscious twists, making it a standout destination for locals and visitors craving fresh, satisfying morning and midday fare.

Bagelsmith's menu is a celebration of variety and quality, offering expertly baked bagels such as their indulgent Pumpernickel Everything Bagel, wholesome Whole Wheat Everything Bagel with Tofu Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese, and the ever-popular Onion Bagel with Cream Cheese. Their vegan options, including the silky, flavorful Vegan Cream Cheese, earn high praise from plant-based diners, perfectly complementing any choice of bagel. For those who relish hearty sandwiches, the Ovengold Turkey Sandwich packed with bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard offers a rewarding burst of savory goodness, while the breakfast sandwiches are crafted to fuel your day with comfort and taste in every bite.

Beyond bagels and sandwiches, Bagelsmith delights with bakery treats like the Raspberry Coffee Cake and a selection of muffins and pastries including buttery croissants and delicate cheese danishes. Accompany your meal with a thoughtfully brewed almond milk latte or one of the shop’s distinctive herbal loose leaf teas — from the soothing Green Tea with Thai Flavors to the warming Hot Cinnamon Spice | Sunset blend — ensuring a harmonious and refreshing experience from start to finish.

The atmosphere here is casual and inviting, primarily designed for quick takeout with a handful of stools at the window for those who wish to stay and soak in the bustle of Brooklyn’s iconic Bedford Avenue. It’s a spot that feels both genuinely local and warmly accommodating — a place where exceptional food meets thoughtful service. This is evident in stories shared by patrons such as Shoshanna Wilford, who experienced Bagelsmith’s dedication firsthand when a small mistake was rectified with kindness, including personally delivering a corrected bagel order straight to her hotel. Such moments highlight the genuine care and commitment that elevate Bagelsmith beyond just a grab-and-go bagel shop.

Whether you’re seeking to start your day with a perfectly toasted bagel layered with creamy, flavorful spreads or craving an all-day sandwich crafted from fresh ingredients, Bagelsmith on Bedford Ave delivers an authentic Brooklyn bagel experience that resonates with heartfelt passion for quality and community. It’s no surprise that regulars, like Amy Hecht and many others, consider it their go-to stop, often bringing these culinary comforts along on travels. Prepare to savor every bite and return time after time to this consummate neighborhood treasure.